From the Desk of the General Counsel: Society for Research on Nicotine and Tobacco Meeting
Greetings from the Society for Research on Nicotine and Tobacco annual meeting in Chicago. The reason for my visit to the Arctic, or what seems like it, is for the most up-to-date vaping and nicotine science discussion. Colleagues from the Vapor Technology Association are also in attendance, tweeting up a storm and keeping our followers updated. This enlightening event presents an opportunity to interact with the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) Center for Tobacco Products (CTP) leadership in anticipation of the FDA deeming rule on vaping products.
The Director of the CTP, Mitch Zeller provided an in-depth perspective on nicotine policy, and examined the FDA’s regulatory science. Mr. Zeller’s first presentation, which I will summarize below, was extremely informative for all in attendance as it outlined the FDA’s expectations and concerns with respect to vaping products.
Mr. Zeller began with a brief overview of the Tobacco Control Act while affirming he would not address or give any updates regarding the upcoming deeming rule (And everyone in the audience was hoping he would spill the beans!).
However, Mr. Zeller did unexpectedly emphasize the need for innovation, a subject very dear to all of us in the industry, who feel obligated to lead the way in new product development. Thus, the FDA’s regulatory policy must encourage all manufacturers to apply the latest technology to create tobacco products proven to reduce risk and exposure to harmful constituents.
Mr. Zeller then turned to his favorite topic – the FDA’s comprehensive Nicotine Regulatory Policy, which includes:
– Developing jurisdictional boundaries ( i.e, classifying Drugs vs. Tobacco products)
– Working with CDER and CDRH (other FDA centers)
– Exploring expedited pre-market review of tobacco products based on relative toxicity and risk
Turning his focus to another important issue, Mr. Zeller clearly explained that there absolutely is a continuum of nicotine containing products and the FDA “understands that people smoke for the nicotine, but die from the tar.” He conceded that there is a public health opportunity to shift smokers to much cleaner, less harmful nicotine delivery products. He also proceeded to point out that kids and pregnant women should abstain from nicotine use.
Mr. Zeller also proposed a very provocative question, “Are we – public health and public opinion – having the right debate?”
The current point of contention has solely been about E-cigarettes, while failing to cover some of the broader, tougher questions. The controversy surrounding vaping products, in his words, is, “emotional, very divisive in tobacco control and filled with misconceptions about nicotine safety,” – such as people mistakenly believing that nicotine causes cancer.
Some of the concerns Mr. Zeller, and his comrades at the FDA would like addressed involve the long-term usage of nicotine without actually smoking conventional cigarettes. Another area is dual use (smoking and vaping), and the appropriate period of transition to the use of only “clean” nicotine. The dilemma is, what if there are differences in opinion between public health officials and the general public? Furthermore, what are the consequences of youth initiation and diminishing interest to quit resulting from dual use?
Mr. Zeller’s final thoughts were very encouraging to all of us who fight for reasonable regulation, commensurate with the harm reduction potential of our products.
He stresses, “We should not be striving for consensus among industry, public health and tobacco, but we should seek some common ground to go forward.”
All I can add is that vapers, too, should have a voice and take an active role in this building consensus. As this is, after all, about people and their health!
You might also like
President Obama has signed the Child Nicotine Poisoning Prevention Act of 2015, and the Vapor Technology Association (VTA), which was just recently launched, has already released its guidelines. In its
Back in 1996, a day was devoted to youth activism against Big Tobacco. Kick Butts Day has been held every year since, with various groups staging events at schools and
There’s no question that 2016 will be remembered for consequential world events and the loss of many beloved public figures. For vaping enthusiasts and retailers, it will also be a year